Quinceaneras = Bat Mitzvahs?

One might not expect to hear “Bat Mitzvah” mentioned in a news report about a rural town with Mexican immigrants whose largest employer is a pork processing plant. But this morning I did. I was listening to a story on NPR about immigration issues in Beardstown, Illinois, a historically white rural community. In part of the story describing racial tensions between the white and Mexican immigrant populations of Beardstown, I was taken by surprise when the reporter explained that a Quinceanera—the traditional 15th birthday celebration in the Hispanic community (which, in Beardstown, had been halted by local police officers, resulting in a major lawsuit)—was “culturally akin to a Bat Mitzvah.”

Before even wondering if such a comparison is accurate, I was amused by the reporter’s assumption that Bat Mitzvah did not require further explanation. Is Bat Mitzvah so comfortably embedded in American cultural knowledge to be exempt from a description? Perhaps for NPR listeners on the East Coast, but I can’t believe that the Jewish rite of passage has become so widely understood by the majority of American radio listeners that it would be a first-choice comparison to Quinceanera over the far more logical “Sweet 16.”

Just for fun, I decided to check out the Wikipedia definitions for Quinceanera and Bat Mitzvah to see how culturally akin they really are.

Quinceanera: “... This celebration marks the transition from childhood to womanhood. It serves as a way to acknowledge that a young woman has reached maturity...” It goes on to detail the traditional color of a Quinceanera dress (pink), the giving of a quince doll (the young woman’s last doll as a child), and a special ceremony in which the birthday girl sits in a chair in the center of the dance floor and removes her flats to put on high heels, signifying her new maturity as a young woman.

Bat Mitzvah (which is included under the general B’nai Mitzvah Wikipedia listing):

“The time when Jewish children reach the age of maturity (12 years for girls, 13 years for boys) and become responsible for their actions. Once a person is Bar or Bat Mitzvah, he or she has the responsibilities of an adult under Jewish law:

- He or she is not innocent anymore, and is responsible for his or her own actions (good or bad). Traditionally, the parents of the Bar or Bat Mitzvah give thanks to God that they no longer have to carry the burden of their child's sins.

- He or she is eligible to be called to read from the Torah, and to participate in a Minyan (In Orthodox denominations, only males read from the Torah or participate in a Minyan).

- He or she is, in theory, legally old enough to be married according to Jewish law.

- He or she must follow the 613 laws of the Torah.”

So there you have it. Quinceaneras and Bat Mitzvahs. Both involve maturity. Both involve sitting in chairs. Part of me thinks that the reporter's choice to use Bat Mitzvah as the comparison to Quinceanera was intentional, as the story focuses upon the struggles of a minority group. But I’m left wondering just how many people—especially those in Beardstown, Illinois—would even know what a Bat Mitzvah is, let alone pronounce it correctly.

Topics: Ritual
6 Comments
The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

Seriously? Your comments are rude. Grow up.

It is extremely unlikely that there were Bat Mitzvah among the CryptoJews of Hispanic America. The first Bat Mitzvah was in 1922 in NYC. The Spanish inquisition was in effect in Mexico until 1821! There were many thousands of Secret Jews in Mexico who had to be vigilant that the Catholic Church would accuse them, seize their property and burn them at the stake. Nevertheless, life goes on. The quincenara may very well have been a Jewish custom to present eligible daughters to preferred families. The dancing around the girl in a chair sounds very similar to a Jewish wedding celebration. Aztecs had no chairs that could be used like that. Aztec elders and lords commonly sat on wooden benches with four legs. Other light and comfortable chairs were icpalli, woven from bulrush reed and you could not lift a person in that. I disagree with Jordan Namerow about almost everything she said. This was a crypto Jewish tradition

I believe the quinceanera was originally a sephardic crypto jewish tradition, of course the catholic church closely monitored them so baptism and confirmation might have been a way to show... we're catholic and not jew. i may be wrong but the shoe seems to fit.

In reply to by Rafa'el

It was not a sephardic crypto jewish tradition. This rite of passage was present in the Americas before people migrated to the Americas. It was present in the civilizations that were here well before the Americas were even discovered.

For most Latinos, the Quince is also has very important religious significance. For example, my catholic friends will not allow their girls to have a Quince until they have been confirmed. My Christian evangelical friends combine the quince with baptism (typically done in their churches during teenage years). In both cases, the young lady is then considered a full, adult member of the church.

That was great! Really well written.

Kudos to you.

Read the latest from JWA from your inbox.

sign up now

Donate

Help us elevate the voices of Jewish women.

donate now

Listen to Our Podcast

Get JWA in your inbox

Read the latest from JWA from your inbox.

sign up now

How to cite this page

Namerow, Jordan. "Quinceaneras = Bat Mitzvahs?." 3 July 2007. Jewish Women's Archive. (Viewed on November 21, 2024) <https://jwa.org/blog/quinceanera>.