You are here

Share Share Share Share Share Share Share
Jewesses with Attitude

My Feminist Nose Job

Yes, I’ve had one.  No I don’t regret it.  

These are the first words that come out of my mouth when the waterfall of questions begins.  That waterfall is quite rare, though; I don’t tell people about my elective surgery. Even my father-in-law doesn’t know; I can only imagine his horror.

My mother says my nose was perfect, petite and cute-- until I hit puberty.  She kept her fingers crossed that I wouldn’t inherit her nose but nature was unkind.  By age fifteen, I had a sniffer so hooked, I could graze it simply by sticking out my tongue.  This unfortunate facial detail was so powerful, it singlehandedly tempered my boisterous personality and outgoing character.  I avoided pictures; I wore my hair in front of my face; I loved hats.  

A week before my fifteenth birthday, I walked into the kitchen and stood in front of my parents as they read the morning paper: “I want it.  I want that nose job.”  Instead of the gasps I expected, they looked at each other and nodded their heads.  

“Ok, tootsie.  Let’s learn more about it.”

My first appointment was slightly underwhelming.  I walked into the surgeon’s office and wanted to know what I would look like, how my life would inevitably change. He had no images, no computer renderings, no words of wisdom; I was forced to imagine.  And I did, without restraint.  I pictured my flowing brown hair, framing a button, a cute protestant nose, the same kind worn by my Texas classmates.  Then the surgeon dropped the bombshell: “You should know that I don’t do those fake celebrity noses…I’ll only do something that will fit your face.”  My mother smiled in appreciation and I shrugged my shoulders thinking: anything will be better than this.

I went to the movies with my best friend Elizabeth (a Christian evangelical) a day before surgery. She was disturbed by my giddiness: “changing what God gave you,” she sighed, shaking her head. 

It wasn’t the first time I heard this.

“I don’t quite share God’s taste,” I said, tapping my nose with a wink.  

The night before surgery, my mother sat with me after dinner.  

“There’s something I want to tell you.” She was very serious.  “I had this same surgery when I was eighteen.”

My jaw dropped in disbelief.

She wanted me to make my own decision, independent of her own.

And that it was; I knew what I was doing.  The surgery was flawless and my friends visited me at home while I convalesced, cotton stuffed up each nostril.

“We prayed for you in Sunday School,” said Elizabeth.

After seven days of house arrest, I was poised for the big reveal.  As the doctor pulled off my mountain of bandages, he handed me the mirror. I looked at the reflection and, despite the swelling and the various shades of black and blue, I felt beautiful.

It was no button, but it was better.

Now, almost fifteen years later, I still keep the rhinoplasty amongst friends. 

Amazingly, the most accepting and “tolerant” individuals can be the most judgmental.  Still, in my mind, I know it was a feminist nose job.  It was about choice and self-determination, and yes, of course, I’ll say it and embrace it….vanity.

I gave to my fifteen year-old-self…and my thirty-year-old self is proud I had the guts to do it.

To learn more about Jewish women and their noses (to change or not to change): check out My Nose, a film by Gayle Kirschenbaum.

Colette Cohen is a local journalist at a Boston NPR station. She studied Jewish history in graduate school but turned to radio so she could tell stories full-time. She lives in Boston with her husband and two babies.

More on: Feminism, Body Image

How to cite this page

Cohen, Colette. "My Feminist Nose Job." 24 May 2010. Jewish Women's Archive. (Viewed on May 30, 2017) <>.


Help us elevate the voices of Jewish women.

donate now

The JWA Podcast

listen now


What Does America Need Right Now?

Sign Up for JWA eNews