You are here

Share Share Share Share Share Share Share

Women's Tefillah Movement

by Bat Sheva Marcus and Ronnie Becher

HISTORY

Orthodox women’s tefillah (prayer) groups consist of women who wish to maximize women’s participation in communal prayer while remaining within the halakhic parameters of the Orthodox community, and so meet regularly to conduct prayer services for women only.

The first women’s tefillah group began in the late 1960s on the holiday of Simhat Torah at Lincoln Square Synagogue in Manhattan. Simhat Torah had proved to be a particularly frustrating experience for Orthodox women as all of its customs and celebrations are tied to the synagogue and formal prayer. Perhaps even more critical was the fact that celebration focused on carrying, dancing, and rejoicing with the Torah scrolls, a practice from which women were excluded. With the support of its rabbi, Shlomo Riskin, the women of Lincoln Square Synagogue were given Torah scrolls for the celebration and permitted to convene a separate Torah reading. Subsequently, it was seen as a major step forward when women in other Orthodox synagogues were also granted the privilege of holding the Torah and taking it to the women’s section. Many groups progressed to conducting full-fledged Simhat Torah services for women only—services in which women read the Torah portion aloud and gave aliyyot to every woman present.

By the late 1970s, a number of groups began to meet monthly. Some of these prayer services were tied to rosh hodesh (the beginning of the month) and the new moon cycle and met on weekdays, while others met once a month on Shabbat. In 1978 and 1979, tefillah groups were formed in Baltimore, Maryland; in St. Paul, Minnesota; and in Riverdale and Washington Heights, New York. In the early 1980s, the first women’s tefillah group in Canada was founded, shortly followed by the Flatbush group in Brooklyn, New York.

During this period, most women’s tefillah groups met in private homes, as Orthodox synagogues were not prepared to sanction the practice. Two notable exceptions in New York were the Riverdale group, which was invited by Rabbi Avi Weiss to meet in the Hebrew Institute of Riverdale, a major Orthodox synagogue, and an East Side group which met in Kehillat Jeshurun under the guidance of Rabbi Haskel Lookstein. Mainstream modern Orthodox rabbis and community leaders rejected women’s tefillah groups for reasons that ranged from the halakhic to the sociological. This issue came to a head in 1985 with publication of the “teshuva: responsum” by five highly regarded Yeshiva University rabbis. The position paper viewed the movement as stemming from, and copying, the feminist movement in America with no serious spiritual or religious basis. It prohibited all organized women’s prayer groups in any form.

The reaction to this public statement was dramatic. Although some rabbis used the statement to justify their prohibition of these prayer groups, a number of well-respected Orthodox rabbinic leaders viewed the document as totally subjective and without serious halakhic basis. This spurred them to take more public roles and action in support of the growing movement. Subsequently, a book was published by Rabbi Weiss entitled Women and Prayer, which analyzed and supported women’s tefillah from a halakhic perspective. Also as a response, the Women’s Tefillah Network (WTN) was born. Through 2000 the network served as a support and resource center for new and existing groups, published regular newsletters, counseled groups, and provided groups with written and taped prayer guides. By the late 1980s, women’s tefillah groups proliferated throughout New York and spread to isolated venues throughout North America. It was difficult to ascertain the exact number of groups. Since the climate was so hostile, many existed “underground.” By 1988, it was estimated that there were twenty groups, and in January of 1997 there were over forty identifiable groups in the United States, Canada, Israel, England, and Australia. These represented nearly four thousand women.

According to the WTN, as of 2000 there were thirty-three women’s tefillah groups in the United States (twenty-two of which were in New York), as well as fifty-seven other groups worldwide, including three in Canada, seven in Israel, two in England, and one in Sydney, Australia. With the formation of the Jewish Orthodox Feminist Alliance (JOFA) that same year, many of the WTN’s services and roles were taken over by the newer, larger organization, and the network itself became less necessary and hence less active.

The advent of Orthodox minyanim that permit a greater participation for women (based on the widely circulated article by Rabbi Mendel Shapiro, originally published in The Edah Journal, 2001) is having a significant impact on the direction of women’s tefillah groups, and so it is unclear what the future role of the groups will be within the Orthodox community.

STRUCTURE

Women’s prayer groups meet monthly to pray, read Torah, and study together. Most groups meet on Shabbat mornings, while others meet on Shabbat afternoons or rosh hodesh weekdays. Generally, full Torah and haftarah portions are read. The women conduct a full service based on guidelines set by their local rabbis. For the most part, women’s tefillah groups do not function as a minyan. This means that they omit specific prayers for which a minyan is required. Thus the status of these groups remains different from that of their male counterparts.

Women’s tefillah groups have become a new arena for women’s life cycle events within the Orthodox community. Celebrations held include simhat bat ceremonies celebrating the birth of a baby girl, bat mitzvah ceremonies, and “afrufs” (lit. “calling up,” an honorary aliyyah on the Shabbat before one’s wedding) for women about to be married. Among the unique practices that have resulted from these groups is the inclusion of a prayer for agunot, women denied religious divorce.

The tefillah groups are attended by women of every age and religious background. Young mothers with babies, older women, preadolescents, teenagers, and college students all participate. This forum allows each of them unique entry into the world of prayer. For some women it affords the opportunity to learn and practice new synagogue skills; for some it provides an opportunity to serve as role models for their children; for some it is a doorway back to the Orthodox community; for some it is a natural extension of leadership that they experience in other areas of their lives.

As feminism continues to influence American Orthodoxy, women’s tefillah groups will remain a viable alternative for Orthodox women who desire a fuller worship experience without leaving Orthodoxy.

More on: Feminism, Prayer, Ritual
2 Comments

The LSS group started in 1972, not "the late 60s", AFAIK, the year my brother was in nursery school there. Mom found the group doing hakafot - they had asked Rabbi Riskin for permission on Yom Tov, he couldn't really send up to Boston for permission from The Rav, so he said "yes", and then The Rav (YBS) gave him guidelines as to how to conduct a women's service. Kinda kil'achar yad, as in "I wouldn't have done it, but if you're going to do it, here's how it should be done."

I think in 1971 there was an impromptu women's davening at an interdenominational women's conference, that was the first contemporary WTG.

From what I hear, the Flatbush group has more or less evaporated, for lack of a permanent home, lack of rabbinic support (no Flatbush rabbi will stick his neck out so far as to allow a WTG), etc.. There is an occasional underground partnership minyan (by invitation only among the hosts' friends)

I recently learned that women-only tefillah with a female prayer leader that is similar to the standard, mixed gender prayer synagogue service is not only a post 1960s phenomenon. There is a little bit of information about it in "A Jewish Woman's Prayer Book" by Aliza Lavie, but I know there must be better articles written. I think it would be a nice complement to this article to have further suggested reading on the history of public women's tefillah. I was very interested to learn about the history of Jewish prayer in practice by women. I think it is also important to record and acknowledge that women's public prayer is not only based on post-1960's feminism, but has a history before this time. This is neither to assert or deny that those earlier practices may have been (or may not have been) "feminist" in their own way, nor is it to minimize the innovation of the 1960's on the contemporary orthodox "scene". Perhaps other people can also recommend books or articles on this topic? Or maybe they are already in the Encyclopedia? I did a search and couldn't find anything, but that doesn't mean its not already in here.

How to cite this page

Becher, Ronnie, and Bat Sheva Marcus. "Women's Tefillah Movement." Jewish Women: A Comprehensive Historical Encyclopedia. 1 March 2009. Jewish Women's Archive. (Viewed on July 21, 2017) <https://jwa.org/encyclopedia/article/womens-tefillah-movement>.

Donate

Help us elevate the voices of Jewish women.

donate now

The JWA Podcast

listen now

Sign Up for JWA eNews

 

Discover Education Programs

Join our growing community of educators.

view programs