Pelech Religious Experimental High School for Girls, Jerusalem
The history of the Pelech School may be roughly divided into three periods: its establishment by Rabbi Shalom and Penina Rosenbluth and the initial phase (1963–1975), its formative years with principal Alice Shalvi (1975–1990), consolidation and ongoing innovation with principal Shira Breuer (1990–).
The very first Pelech was set up in the clubhouse of the Bnei Akiva youth movement in Pardes Hannah in 1963. Rabbi Shalom Rosenbluth (October 1, 1917–December 13, 2003) and his wife Penina (b. December 12, 1926), two highly educated and cultured teachers, were seeking to provide an educational alternative for their daughter. When they moved to Jerusalem three years later, Pelech moved with them, relocated in a children’s nursery in the Bayit va-Gan neighborhood of Jerusalem. The first Pelech was an ultra-orthodox (Haredi) school, seeking to provide a broad-cultured learning alternative to the Bais Ya’akov network.
From its outset, the curriculum included Talmud (Gemara) as a compulsory subject. This was a revolutionary step within the Israeli religious educational system; Talmud was off limits to ultra-orthodox Haredi girls and traditionally reserved for boys within the state religious system. “Reb Sholom” and Penina invested all their energies and resources into the school, introducing a variety of subjects and teaching curriculum previously unknown in the religious school system.
Some time after the Six Day War, Reb Sholom managed to persuade the Ministry of Religious Affairs to rent Pelech an abandoned building on Mount Zion. With a student population of just fifty girls in all four grades, there was no need for full-time staff. The Rosenbluths themselves were more than accomplished teachers. Reb Sholom himself taught Talmud, mathematics and physics while Penina taught English. Other teachers taught several classes each week, often as a personal favor to the Rosenbluths. The staff comprised an illustrious group of up-and-coming academics who would go on to become renowned university professors and community leaders including Rabbi Yehuda Amital, Rabbi Mordechai Breuer, Professor Andre Neher and Dr. Hananel Mack.
Within a short time, Pelech was causing controversy and was put under herem by the Haredim (ultra-orthodox), the very community it had sought to enlighten. It did, however, appeal to the modern orthodox community in Jerusalem, who had long felt the need for a less parochial, broad-based approach to girls’ education. Families headed by well-known academics, community leaders and members of the free professions started to send their daughters to Pelech. Alice Shalvi’s involvement with Pelech began as a parent when seeking an alternative educational environment for the oldest of her three daughters.
The Yom Kippur War, which broke out in October 1973 and dragged on for almost a year, marked the first of several crises for the fledgling school. Most of the male teachers were drafted, leaving Reb Sholom to teach nearly all the classes. The terrorist attack on the school in Ma’alot in 1974 shocked the parent body of Pelech into awareness of the vulnerability of the girls in a remote location. Added to this was the ongoing physical and financial drain on the private resources of the Rosenbluths. Pelech had still not received accreditation from the Ministry of Education. Those parents who could afford it paid fees, but the remaining expenses, including the renovation of the dilapidated building, had been covered by them personally. In an effort to attract more students, Pelech had, at one time, provided dormitory facilities and a summer school. Penina Rosenbluth had personally borne the physical strain of running these facilities.
In the final analysis, Pelech was now educating a very different population from the one the Rosenbluths had planned. In the spring of 1975, after much effort, adversity and disappointment, the Rosenbluths sadly declared their intention of closing the school at the end of that academic year.
It was at this point that those parents who had come to appreciate the school’s philosophy and profound difference, in principle and practice, from other religious high schools for girls determined to work together to ensure its future. Alice Shalvi volunteered her services for a limited period with the aim of taking the administrative load off the Rosenbluths and enabling them to continue the educational side. Much to her surprise, she found herself being introduced as the school’s new principal. It was to take over her life for the next fifteen years.
In 1975 Pelech moved to highly unsuitable premises in an apartment building in Bayit va-Gan. In a crowded four-room apartment, Alice Shalvi set about hiring staff—young people (mainly women)—to join her in an educational adventure that would set a new path in girls’ high school education. Physically, conditions were worse than ever, but educationally, her timing could not have been better. David Pur, the founding principal of the innovative school at Kibbutz Givat Brenner, had just been appointed head of high school education at the Ministry of Education. His educational reform granted greater autonomy to schools that wished to implement innovative courses and methods. Alice Shalvi was not trained as a high school teacher; she was a Hebrew University lecturer in English literature, specializing in Shakespeare. But her educational vision, creative curricula and frequently outrageous experiments were just what the Ministry was looking for. After three years of hard work, Pelech was accredited as one of the (then) only two officially recognized “experimental” high schools.
In 1976 the school was on the move once again as the municipality inexplicably decided that it required the totally inappropriate premises for a new secular primary school that the authorities wanted to establish in the predominantly orthodox neighborhood. Pelech was allocated an abandoned three-storey house in the then-dubious (but later gentrified) neighborhood of Bak’ah. In return for Pelech’s renovating the building, installing central heating and planting a garden, the municipality waived the rent payments. An outhouse was converted to an all-purpose science laboratory and a toilet was converted into a staff room. Thus began the years of innovation and excellence for which the school rapidly became renowned.
In determining the educational philosophy of Pelech, Alice Shalvi first relied on her personal experience as a mother and her feminist conviction that no area of knowledge should be inaccessible to girls and women on grounds of sex. She was also inspired by the work of several educators, including David Pur and Daniel and Hannah Greenberg, who had founded the Sudbury Valley School near Boston. This totally child-centered and student-governed school provided the model for the democratic institutions of government that were initiated at Pelech.
Some of the most important achievements from this period include the following:
- The Student Council as a democratic institution which involves students and teachers in the decision making process of the school.
- New modes of evaluation, including “take-home examinations” and “library examinations” that test the student’s research abilities and personal integrity.
- Personal tutors who reinforce the work of the home room teachers by meeting regularly with each student to monitor their educational, social and emotional progress.
- Introduction of Environmental Studies, Yiddish and Theater.
- An interdisciplinary Humanities Course combining sociopolitical and economic history studies (including Jewish history) with the study of literature, art, music and philosophy.
- “Israeli Society”: a four year course replacing the civics course required by the Ministry of Education with study of Israel’s ethnic composition, institutions of government and their interface with Jewish tradition.
- Family Studies: including units on nutrition, choice of a life partner, family planning, child psychology and the parental role in child development. The halakhic aspects were integrated at every stage to include dietary laws, family purity (taharat ha-mishpahah) and rulings on contraception.
- Conflict and Conflict Resolution: developed after the outbreak of the first Intifada in 1988 by deputy principal Aryeh Geiger, together with philosophy teacher Shulamith Levy, herself a Pelech graduate, to provide a multi-faceted approach to the divisions within Israeli society, comprising traditional moral Jewish principles and modern methods of social dynamics and psychotherapy. The program included meetings with students from different sectors of Israeli society, which was unusual at that time, including students from secular schools and Palestinian Arab schools in east Jerusalem.
Pelech thrived in an atmosphere of creativity, innovation and social commitment. The family atmosphere within the school and open channels of communication between teachers and students were legendary. It became difficult to get accepted, with three girls competing for every available place. In 1993 (after the Shalvi period but based primarily on the work carried out during her years), Pelech received the Israel Education Prize for its pioneering educational work. The majority of classes still took place in the cramped, though moderately renovated house on Gideon Street, but happily, thanks to Shalvi’s tireless fundraising activities, the school was now solvent enough to invest in purpose-built science laboratories and a beautiful beit midrash in a nearby historically-protected building.
Controversy has played its role in the history of Pelech. The school’s insistence on encouraging its graduates to serve in certain units of the Israel Defense Forces set a new precedent for religious girls in Israel. An uphill battle with the Ministry of Education to receive recognition for Pelech experimental programs at bagrut (matriculation) level was ultimately successful and provided a precedent that benefited other schools. Not all adversity is settled so easily and the controversy concerning the perceived clash between Alice Shalvi’s political activities—both with Palestinian women and as head of a feminist organization, the Israel Women’s Network—and her tenure as principal of a religious high school finally came to a head in 1990, precipitating her resignation.
After several months of uncertainty regarding Alice Shalvi’s successor, the Board of Governors appointed Shira Breuer as the new principal of Pelech. Breuer was a young, accomplished history teacher who had worked at Pelech since 1986. American-born, Israeli-educated, Shira Breuer, like the previous principals of Pelech, has imprinted her own individual style on the ongoing history of Pelech.
In 1998 the Jerusalem Municipality granted Pelech the use of a renovated school building, previously the Nitzanim School, adjacent to Pelech’s Beit Midrash building. The improved facilities—including a purpose-designed library, an auditorium, dance studio, art room, computer laboratory and appropriate staff accommodation—have facilitated greater teaching options and a more relaxed atmosphere.
Many of the original programs described previously have continued at the school, adapted to the changing needs of today. The personal counselor system, the student council and the honor system remain pivots of the Pelech educational philosophy. Several programs have been expanded. The interdisciplinary humanities program now includes an expressive, experiential unit combining “Bible and Art.” The volunteerism unit has been intensified to include weekly computer lessons for local pensioners and daily private enrichment classes for local elementary school children. The interdisciplinary science curriculum includes an innovative unit combining physics and computers.
There have been many new additions to the teaching program including
- Mathematics and Graphic Computers: a national school experiment first introduced at Pelech.
- Feminism and Philosophy: an interdisciplinary program combining traditional sources and feminist texts defining the identity of the Jewish woman.
- “Tekufot” (semesters): an intensive, subject-based reorganization of the school schedule based on the concept of the university semester to increase the level of study and research. This is a pioneering methodology that has redefined Pelech’s experimental status with the Ministry of Education.
- Special Education Class: one group is accepted to Pelech every four years. Development of innovative academic program to bagrut (matriculation) level and full participation and integration in the informal education program.
- Option of an additional year, following graduation, to improve bagrut grades and prepare for army and national service.
The religious identity of Pelech has matured, reflecting the changes that have taken place in the modern orthodox community. Twelfth-grade students study Daf Yomi (literally: a daily page of Talmud) and have increased the tractates of Talmud they study—not for grades, but because they love it. Kri’at ha-Torah (Torah reading) takes place voluntarily and without a blessing every Rosh Hodesh (first day of the new month). Every year, on Purim, a women’s Megillah (the Book of Esther) reading by the students takes place at the school. In 2004, a women’s Hakhnasat Sefer Torah (inauguration of a Torah scroll) took place at the school, with the participation of hundreds.
Although many schools have introduced Pelech methods into their teaching program, the opening of a second Pelech School in September 2000 in Kiryat Ekron, Rehovot, was a major landmark. The school was the initiative of a group of parents who were familiar with the Pelech model as an alternative to their local religious state schools. Shira Breuer and the Pelech staff were deeply involved in the establishment of the school and the two schools remain in close contact educationally. As with the original Pelech, Pelech Kiryat Ekron has also had to deal with controversy and criticism from the local religious community. At one time it was unclear if it would survive. However, from its modest start, with two classes of seventh- and eighth-graders, it is now a fully-fledged high school based on the Pelech educational philosophy and implementing Pelech programs under the leadership of principal Yonit Yakobovitch.
Pelech was and still is recognized as an educational model and educators from many different schools in Israel and abroad have introduced its methods. A number of educators and graduates from Pelech have themselves become school principals and have taken the Pelech experience with them. Over two thousand graduates have also taken the Pelech experience with them and this was, in essence, Pelech’s primary aim: to instill the values of religious commitment and broad culture, to further religious women’s leadership and to prepare students to take their place as informed, committed, active members of society.
It is definitely time for a professional survey of the occupations of Pelech graduates. A mini-survey carried out at the school in 1999 showed a significant number of graduates involved in the caring professions: education, social work and psychology. A number of graduates have returned to teach at Pelech and in recent years five out of eight homeroom teachers were graduates.
Thirty years on, Talmud learning for women is a recognized fact and Pelech graduates have been conspicuously involved in the establishment and ongoing activities of the Batei Midrash (learning groups, particularly of Talmud) that have proliferated in the modern orthodox community. They have been prominent in the establishment of alternative minyanim (prayer groups) and in lobbying for the improved status of women in issues of halakhah (Jewish Law).
It may be said that the improved status of women within the modern orthodox community over the last ten years has enabled Pelech to establish a new identity. The converse has also been suggested: that Pelech has contributed to the improved status of religious women.
Shalvi, Alice. “‘Women’s Wisdom Has Built Its Home’—A Highly Personal Account of the Pelech Experiment.” In Studies in Jewish Education, vol. 7, edited by Walter Ackerman. Jerusalem: 1995.
How to cite this page
Lawson, Naomi. "Pelech Religious Experimental High School for Girls, Jerusalem." Jewish Women: A Comprehensive Historical Encyclopedia. 1 March 2009. Jewish Women's Archive. (Viewed on November 17, 2018) <https://jwa.org/encyclopedia/article/pelech-religious-experimental-high-school-for-girls-jerusalem>.