Carol Weiss King

August 24, 1895–January 22, 1952

by Bernard Unti

In Brief

Carol Weiss King took up the family business of law but rejected her family’s upper-crust background to become a pioneer of labor rights. At the beginning of her law career, she championed cases of immigrants and left-wing activists, and from 1924 to 1931 she edited the ACLU’s Law and Freedom Bulletin, documenting constitutional law cases for other activists to use as precedents. She founded the International Juridical Association and the National Lawyers Guild. In 1942 she became general counsel to the American Committee for the Foreign Born. She withstood FBI surveillance and took pride in her victories against the Immigration and Naturalization Service. Many of her cases went to the Supreme Court, and she often had male lawyers argue her cases to avoid sexism affecting the outcomes.

Family and Education

Carol Weiss King was one of the outstanding practitioners of immigration law during the period bounded by the Palmer Raids and the McCarthy era. In her thirty-year career, she represented hundreds of foreign-born radicals threatened with deportation in administrative proceedings in the lower courts and in the Supreme Court.

King was born on August 24, 1895, to Samuel and Carrie (Stix) Weiss. Their youngest child, she had two brothers and one sister. Samuel Weiss founded the law firm, Frank and Weiss, which lasted less than five years. Samuel then became a very successful sole practitioner from 1880 until his death in 1910. Carol's eldest brother William S. Weiss graduated from Columbia Law that same year and kept his father's practice going until multiple sclerosis forced him to recede from the practice of law. Another older brother of Carol, Louis, was a founding partner of Paul, Weiss, Rifkind, Wharton & Garrison. The Weiss children were raised in a caring, liberal, intellectual environment. At Barnard College, from which she graduated in 1916, King developed a deep interest in the problems of labor and volunteered to work with Local 25 of the International Ladies Garment Workers Union. She wed author Gordon King in 1917.

Career and Accomplishments

After graduating from New York University Law School in 1920, King spurned her family’s affluent lifestyle and Wall Street legal practice for a loose partnership with radical attorneys Joseph Brodsky, Swinburne Hale, Walter Nelles, and Isaac Shorr. This early experience led to a lifelong association with left-wing activists, including members of the Communist Party of the United States. From 1924 to 1931, King edited the Law and Freedom Bulletin, the important digest of the American Civil Liberties Union and one of the country’s earliest efforts to record state and federal cases involving significant questions of constitutional law. She became a founder and principal of the International Juridical Association and the National Lawyers Guild. In 1942, she became general counsel to the American Committee for the Foreign Born. Her clients included union leader Harry Bridges, Communist Party leader William Schneiderman, Negro Communist organizer Angelo Herndon, the Scottsboro Boys, and numerous left-wing activists.

One of Carol Weiss King's first and most durable relationships was with Walter Pollak, a onetime partner of Benjamin Cardozo whom she met through her brother-in-law Carl Stern. The three of them worked on the Scottsboro Boys cases, which Pollak successfully argued in the U.S. Supreme Court, as well as a number of other cases. Walter Pollak's son, Senior U.S. District Judge Louis Pollak, who married Carol's niece, wrote the Forward to Ann Ginger's definitive biography of King.

When her husband died of pneumonia in 1930, leaving King a widow with one son, she threw herself into her work. Her best-known client was the colorful Bridges, who faced deportation in 1938 for alleged membership in the Communist Party. King guided the Australian-born longshoreman’s case through several rounds, until the Supreme Court reversed the deportation order during World War II.

King had an extraordinary record of success in enlisting other attorneys to work for free on key constitutional cases. Her most significant accomplishment in this regard was her recruitment of Wendell Willkie, the 1940 Republican Party presidential nominee, to represent her client William Schneiderman in the Supreme Court. The case, in which the U.S. Government tried to revoke the Communist Party leader’s citizenship, was decided favorably in 1943.

As a female attorney in a predominantly male-dominated profession, and unwilling to let her clients’ interests be compromised by sexist assumptions about their advocate, King frequently retained men to argue cases that she herself had prepared. Although a number of her cases reached the Supreme Court, she herself made only one appearance there, in Butterfield v. Zydok (342 U.S. 524, 1952), a case in which her client lost.

Because of her association with controversial clients, King herself was subject to surveillance by the FBI. She took special satisfaction in her battles against the Immigration and Naturalization Service (INS). Her most important legal victory against the INS came in Sung v. McGrath (339 U.S. 908, 1950), in which the Supreme Court acknowledged her argument that the agency was subject to the same administrative and procedural rules as all other federal departments. This ruling resulted in an immediate freeze on deportation hearings until the INS agreed to comply with the requirements of the Administrative Procedures Act.

After a bout with cancer, Carol Weiss King died on January 22, 1952.

Bibliography

ACLU Law and Freedom Bulletin (1924–1931).

DAB 5:389–390

Ginger, Ann Fagan. Carol Weiss King (1993).

King, Carol Weiss. Papers. Carol Weiss King Collection. Meiklejohn Civil Liberties Institute, Berkeley, Calif.

King, Carol Weiss, and Walter Nelles. “Contempt by Publication in the United States.” Columbia Law Review 28 (1928).

NAW modern; Obituary. NYTimes, January 23, 1952, 27:1.

Have an update or correction? Let us know

Donate

Help us elevate the voices of Jewish women.

donate now

Get JWA in your inbox

Read the latest from JWA from your inbox.

sign up now

How to cite this page

Unti, Bernard. "Carol Weiss King." Shalvi/Hyman Encyclopedia of Jewish Women. 27 February 2009. Jewish Women's Archive. (Viewed on May 21, 2024) <http://jwa.org/encyclopedia/article/king-carol-weiss>.