You are here

Share Share Share Share Share Share Share
Blog:
Jewesses with Attitude

Taking the "Rihanna" approach to Jewish Orthodox sexuality

I was a little surprised to see how much frank talk about sex was featured in The Sisterhood this week. As a teenager, I am used to people around me talking about sex a lot--in real life, in movies, in songs, in basically every medium except in Jewish blogs. But that is no longer!

It was interesting for me to read about how many women have been affected by the lack of frank discussion of sex and sexuality in Judaism, and how many women go through their lives without really talking about sex or their sexual needs. On one hand, I find that foreign, because people around me talk about sex all the time. On the other hand, when I thought about it, so much of the portrayal of sex in the media is skewed--there is a lot of woman-bashing, perpetration of sexual stereotypes, and very little emphasis on what women actually want. Sounds kind of similar to the complaints Jewish women have about their own lack of sexual literacy.

So I thought that I'd share this music video by Rihanna, an internationally known pop artist, as an example of some of the contradictions in the portrayal of sex in the media today and what they mean for the way women see their sexuality.

On one hand, the video is clearly very sexual, to the point that it is somewhat uncomfortable to watch. Rihanna wears very little clothing, and the entire video could be seen as demeaning to Rihanna in the way that she uses her body to get people to watch her video and listen to her music. However, if you listen to the lyrics, the discussion gets somewhat more complicated when she says things like "Boy, I want, want, want whatchu want, want, want," "Relax, let me do it how I wanna" and "Babe, if I don't feel it I ain't faking, no, no." She declares that she has sexual needs just like any man and makes it clear that she expects to be satisfied. The picture she paints is nowhere near perfect, clearly--Rude Boy doesn't teach any kind of actual safe sex education. However, it still paints the picture of a strong woman who will not settle for a man who will not please her.

Personally, I think that it is important that songs like this exist. Its not my favorite song, to say the least, but I find it somewhat empowering to know that a woman can write a song about her sexual demands just like so many men write songs about what they want from women. And while it is easy to write Rude Boy off as an overly sexual pop video (which I believe it is, to an extent), it also serves as a counterpoint to too many overly sexual pop videos that portray women as having no sexual needs. Girls today, used to hearing songs like Right Round and Gimme Head (this is not a joke), have gotten used to only thinking about sex in terms of men's needs. Is Rude Boy perfect? No. But is it a step in the right direction? I believe that it is.

So what does this really have to do with Judaism? At least in the Orthodox world, many women feel that there is the same lack of honest acknowledgement of women's sexual needs as there is in the media. And because it takes time to cultivate that kind of change in perspective, just like it does in the media, I think we could use a Rihanna of the Jewish world--someone who knows her audience, but also knows that if you go about it the right way, you can slowly change people's idea about sexuality. It's a very different audience, I'll admit, but the same principle should be followed: talk to people about things in a way that they are used to, one that will make them likely to listen.

So how do we move towards that? A 2009 study conducted by Dr. Michelle Friedman, Director of Pastoral Counseling at Yeshivat Chovevei Torah Rabbinical School, and a larger team of researchers on sexual behavior among religious couples, women expressed how much they wished that they had been taught about their bodies, men's bodies, and Jewish views on a woman's right to pleasure, among many other things, before marriage. I think the fact that this study and the discussions going on in The Sisterhood article above exist is a step in the right direction: getting Orthodox women to openly acknowledge the gaps in their sexual education. Now hopefully, the next step will be to fill those gaps. I'm not sure exactly how--perhaps by religious leaders involving women in discussions on their sexual lives, or through Rabbi-approved books on sexuality, or through some other means of reaching out to women. But whichever way works, I think that it's important, for Jewish and non-Jewish women alike, that these gaps begin to be filled.

Dina Lamdany is a Washington D.C. high school student and aspiring feminist who blogs at from the rib.

4 Comments

Hmm, I interpreted as the opposite, despite the wink - and found her assertion that no, she's not going to fake it, to be pretty progessive.

What bothers me most in the video for "Rude Boy" is when Rihanna sings "Babe, if I don't feel it I ain't faking, no, no" she winks, suggesting that she will fake it. Why? Why this message? It undermines her point.

Why does Rhianna's choice of dress have to be for a male audience? I don't deny that it has this effect on men that Dov describes. But at the same time, isn't that just a male-centric point-of-view? Her dressing sexy is part of her demand to be please sexually. How would you like to see her dressed? In jeans and a t-shirt? Women have the right to dress sexy for themselves, to make themselves feel sexy. By claiming that she just dresses this way to please men is denying her the right to express herself by way of dress.

Hi Dina, I enjoyed this post a great deal. As a man who is also pro womans rights and a woman's right to tell her sexual needs I find this post, and the discussion that comes with it, extremely interesting. So in her video, Rihanna, makes sexual demands and yet it is so clearly catered towards pleasing men visually. If we look past the fact that most hip-hop and rap music videos do this, I almost wonder if this was very intentional on Rihanna's part. How to you get men to listen to you? Well, as a man, I know you do something pretty provocative. This isn't always the case, but its a sure bet to work. Do you think that Rihanna did this so that she could ensure men would listen to her music and hear this message. Even if you are focusing on her body the entire time, you can't get around the lyrics which are clearly her expressing her sexual desires. Rihanna has successfully voiced your concerns (womens' sexual needs) to a large male audience (by exploiting our deepest weaknes!!!) If you ask me, in order for the world to know about womens' sexuality you might want to do it in the form of a hip-hop music video. I know it may sound demeaning, and I can understand your issues with it, but if it works, it works.

How to cite this page

Lamdany, Dina. "Taking the "Rihanna" approach to Jewish Orthodox sexuality." 14 May 2010. Jewish Women's Archive. (Viewed on May 26, 2017) <https://jwa.org/blog/the-rihanna-approach>.

Donate

Help us elevate the voices of Jewish women.

donate now

The JWA Podcast

listen now

Poll

What Does America Need Right Now?

Sign Up for JWA eNews

 

Twitter

14 hr
in 1910, this political trailblazer won the fight to regulate New York City's dance halls. https://t.co/S3AkJrJ5P3
15 hr
This documentary looks pretty amazing, we must say. https://t.co/u3FDcInjTG