March is Women's History Month! Please consider a gift of $18 to JWA today, so we can continue bringing you the important, fascinating history of Jewish women. Donate here
Close [x]

Show [+]

You are here

Share Share Share Share Share Share Share
Blog:
Jewesses with Attitude

Changing Targets: Technology and Jewish Education

Earlier this week I listened in on the “Technology and Jewish Education” conference organized by the Lippman Kanfer Institute and Berman Jewish Policy Archive @ NYU Wagner, held at the JESNA offices in New York. I heard many familiar themes: Jewish education is underfunded, and in particular Jewish educators lack both resources and training to take advantage of technology. At the same time, the environment in which students today learn seems to rely increasingly on mobile devices and Facebook feeds—even more than my generation relied on bulky film projectors and film strip readers (both of which proved difficult for some teachers, who relied on us students to make the machinery work). Funding is also lacking to develop tools key to teaching Jewish subjects—to develop specialized software, for instance, or ensure access to significant Jewish texts, with translation(s).

Lisa Colton of Darim Online reminded us that technology should be the means, not the end—the real goal must remain one of Jewish education.

Meredith Lewis, of MyJewishLearning.com, spoke of how her site helps people looking for answers to specific questions, often phrased in ways that make it clear that the person asking has no understanding of Jewish traditions or cultures. In this she sees few signs of specific “Jewish learning,” if the term implies some engagement with Jewish life and continuity.

In a dinner-time address, Jeffrey Shandler reminded the audience that the challenge of technology as it meets Jewish (or religious) life is not new. He used the controversies around advent of the printing press and what it meant for Jewish learning, and the more recent example, in the US, of the advent of radio to drive home the point.

All of this suggests that technology is a stand-in for a larger problem, what it means to talk about “Jewish Education.” The term refers to more than the formal education provided by synagogue or day school educators. In yesterday’s discussion it also included the self-paced inquiry and learning as experienced by an individual on the web. Yet, as David Bryfman and others pointed out, putting tools to learn to chant Torah online is answering educational questions that, for many, are largely irrelevant to a community that is far more diverse, and far more diffuse than that experienced even 200 years ago. The question goes beyond technology to the diversity of ways being “Jewish” will be defined in this and in coming generations.

Dan Sieradski’s pleas for Open Source texts and tools to enable an unaffiliated individual learn to chant from the Torah highlight another non-technical question: What does it mean to acquire education? Is it enough to put Jewish resources online so that, like Madonna and her Kaballah “practice,” passers by can pick up what they choose? If one learns to chant a Bat Mitzvah torah portion without learning anything about Jewish history or culture, has one really become a Bat Mitzvah? Is it meaningful to become acculturated into a Jewish community of one?

To the contrary, most of us would argue that if one acquires knowledge without engagement, without learning about Jewish history, culture, and community in context, one has not become a member of the Jewish community.

The Jewish Women’s Archive has always served multiple audiences. Our search logs and site surveys indicate that the more information we put online, with more detail—the more people come to our site. Publishing the Jewish Women’s Encyclopedia online last year was a game-changer and had a tremendous, positive effect on the sheer number of people visiting our site. Usage logs and site surveys indicate that many of the people using our site are students preparing reports for religious studies and the like. Our materials are encountered by everyone from those seeking specific knowledge, to those looking for community and continuity.

Those same people post updates to articles, comment on the blog, submit pieces to “We Remember,” and use our latest project, a Google maps "mashup" to put Jewish women “On the Map.”

We also serve Jewish educators directly, both in providing materials to highlight broader Jewish American Culture, from pioneers of the Western United States to Civil Rights and Labor leaders; and by providing women’s voices to tell those stories, reminding both teachers and students that women, too, play a significant role in arts, culture, and political struggle. Indeed, in the last five years over 30,000 lesson plans have been downloaded from our site, countless more educators have used our “Primary Sources,” and starting this summer, more will be able to focus on Living the Legacy Jewish participation in the Civil Rights and Labor movements, using not only lesson plans and primary resources from our site, but objects uploaded by students or available on other websites. Our Bat Mitzvah Interactive project moves that critical rite of passage beyond learning a Torah portion for cultural engagement and continuity.

We have always used the latest technology, standards-based when possible to meet the needs of both the Jewish community and Jewish educators—including the independent self-educators championed by Dan Sieradski. Further, by defining ourselves as an “Online Archive” we rely on Internet technology for all access and learning.

But we don’t exist for the sake of technology. Once downloaded, our materials can be used in many other contexts. We use technology not just to “uncover, chronicle, and transmit to a broad public the rich history of American Jewish women.” It is technology that provides us tools to engage students, teachers, and the diversity of casual seekers forwarded to the site by Google and Bing so that their rich history becomes our history.

In a world where what it means to be Jewish and a part of the Jewish community—like technology—is always changing, so too will Jewish education remain in flux. Maybe that is the lesson of this week’s conference—it isn’t just technology that keeps changing on us; it is our understanding of community and its continuity as well.

6 Comments

Jewish education, like the rest of life, takes place within a matrix of computer-mediated connections that enable and inform the interpenetration of the online and offline realms. No existing movement or organization can encompass this continuum of Jewish experiences. The Jewish student who is considering a Birthright trip emails for information, texts a few friends to see who else is interested, Googles the latest news from Israel, and organizes on Facebook an evening of hanging out with those friends. After the trip they join other Birthright alumni on Facebook, and meet at the local Hillel for Shabbat dinner. Online and offline are completely intertwined and interdependent, and not only for the young. The challenge of Jewish education is to find the places to intervene with elements of Jewish life and culture that are not immediately obvious in the "cloud" of online information, and orchestrate offline encounters with them. Why is it important that a Torah is written on parchment and not only available electronically? What does that say about a community that must generate the organization and resources to produce and protect a Torah? What would an online/offline community with those capabilities -- and that would appeal to them -- look like? To my mind, those are some of the foundational issues facing Jewish education.

Ari Davidow asks what it means to talk about Jewish education. In a recent article, Prof. Jack Wertheimer discusses the changing attitudes toward Jewish education in the United States and what it means for the future. The article can be read at http://www.jewishideasdaily.co...

This is a really thoughtful post, Ari! Thank you. I also enjoyed your clear description of JWA's work in the context of Jewish education, use of technology, and continuity.

You make some great points. I also attended the conference online. Your question "is it enough to put Jewish resources online...?" is a great one. I think putting resources online is a step in the right direction, but it's important to have community and interaction online as well. I also think it's naive to assume, as some Jewish educators do, that most Jews show up at synagogue and seek Jewish education. The reality is that less than 50% of American Jews affiliate, and of those who do, few participate regularly. Thus, it is so important for us to have quality resources and opportunities for a contemporary Jewish community online. Check out www.OurJewishCommunity.org to see how we are bringing Judaism to people where they are.

These are all very interesting observations. Regarding Ari's question about whether the bat mitzvah girl who learns to chant Torah online is missing out on other facets of her Jewish education. The answer is yes, but let's not throw out the baby with the bathwater.

If that young girl lives in a remote area of the country (or world) in which no bat mitzvah tutors are in close proximity, then she and her parents should be thankful for the modern technology that allows her to prepare for her bat mitzvah through the Internet.

Yes, there are still other pieces of her Jewish educational puzzle that will not be solved online. However, it has to be one step at a time.The girl learns to chant her bat mitzvah Torah portion online and in doing so wants to learn more about Jewish history and culture. She asks her parents to send her to a Jewish camp that summer to meet other Jewish children and to be engaged in informal Jewish education. She is no longer a "Jewish community of one" and all because the online bat mitzvah preparation experience led to her becoming part of a larger community outside of her geographical borders.

Rabbi Jason Miller

Jewish Techs blog (The NY Jewish Week)

http://www.thejewishweek.com/b...

I couldn't agree more. Technology will always progress. Change is inevitable. To ignore the changes is to miss a huge opportunity to revolutionize the learning and make it fun for the next generation. The challenge is how to bring these new resources to bear on the learning process.

I've taken my first steps with my new iPhone app - http://www.iwritehebrew.com. It's a simple game-like app for kids to learn how to print Hebrew letters. Soon, I hope to have cursive as well as other languages enabled.Of course, the app doesn't teach you everything about Hebrew, but it's a start. Learning a language is a challenging endeavor for anyone. But we should find new ways to stimulate our kids and ourselves in the context of the new technologies that arise.

How to cite this page

Davidow, Ari. "Changing Targets: Technology and Jewish Education." 7 May 2010. Jewish Women's Archive. (Viewed on March 29, 2017) <https://jwa.org/blog/technology-and-Jewish-education>.

Donate

Help us elevate the voices of Jewish women.

donate now

Poll

What is the best Jewish feminist tv show currently on tv?

Sign Up for JWA eNews

 

Twitter

12 hr
The ONLY way for ladies to learn about science, naturally. https://t.co/qi2OkvPxWu
13 hr
This article about the Triangle Shirtwaist Factory fire... prepare to get sad and mad. https://t.co/onHyxvxx0N
14 hr
How the word "camp" is often used to diminish women's stories and accomplishments. https://t.co/Hv6hBIN0B9