Scout Me In
On February 1, 2019, Boy Scouts of America—the iconic American scouting organization—changed the name of its more than 100-year-old Boy Scouts program to Scouts BSA and opened its membership to girls. This long-awaited change is something that many people, including myself, have dreamed about. I have always admired Eagle Scouts and was attracted to the opportunity for frequent camping trips, combined with learning outdoor and leadership skills, but I never thought I would have the same chance as my brother to participate in this outdoor-focused program.
When I learned of this revolutionary change to allow girls into Boy Scouting (now Scouts BSA), my dreams finally came true, and my many hours of complaining about the unfairness of my brother’s frequent campouts and hikes were over. (Boy Scouts of America already offered three other programs—Cub Scouting, Venturing, and Sea Scouting—to girls, but they were not as readily available to me.) I immediately started researching exactly what Scouting would entail and became a founding member of Scouts BSA Troop 792, Soaring Eagle District, Heart of America Council. Shortly after our troop was formed, I was elected Assistant Senior Patrol Leader, essentially the second-highest leader in the troop.
The opportunity to be a trailblazer in Scouting reminded me of RBG and how she was a trailblazer in the legal field, one of only nine women in her Harvard Law School class of 500. Today, there are as many female law students as male. In just four months, thousands of girls have joined Scouts BSA, and I hope that one day equal numbers of boys and girls will participate in Scouting.
Since joining Scouts BSA, I have learned the Scout Oath and Law, how to tie various knots, and how to catch and fillet a fish. I have also learned valuable leadership skills and tools that I will use for the rest of my life. The moral values and strong ethics that Scouting teaches are things everyone can learn from and use, and they are important regardless of gender. Everyone can strive to be “physically strong, mentally awake, and morally straight.”
Although the transition into allowing girls has been largely well-received and most people have been incredibly supportive, it hasn’t been perfect. A few male scouts and leaders have called us “girl Scouts” instead of “Scouts,” which is unfortunate both because they are using the term “girl” pejoratively, and they’re suggesting that we are somehow separate from them and not full Scouts.
On a recent camp out where we shared a few activities with a boys-only troop, a few boys accused us of watching Netflix on a phone (something that is never allowed on a campout), when in fact we were practicing knots and playing a card game after having spent the morning fishing. I’m sure that these boys’ intent was not malicious or inherently sexist, but it suggested that they thought we might be less serious about Scouting than they are. While it may take time for some people to get used to having girls participate in Scouts BSA, I think that our presence, being the best Scouts we can be, and speaking up when we hear inappropriate remarks, will dispel people’s preconceived notions and negative attitudes about girls in Scouting.
I’m a Scout, but I’m also a Jewish Scout. Religion is an important part of the Scouting program. The Scout oath includes the line “to do my duty to G-d” and part of the Scout law is to be reverent in particular towards G-d. This reverence can stem from any religion or belief system; it is more about believing in something than what you actually believe in. This is special to me because as a student at a Jewish day school, almost all of my religious experiences are structured. But in Scouts, reverence can be unstructured, and I get to connect with G-d in an entirely different way. Instead of praying in a synagogue or at school, I get to be outside in nature experiencing the beauty and wonder of the world. I don’t have to say a specific prayer or blessing to feel a connection to G-d. This is the magic of Scouting: getting to experience something unique and special that is, at the same time, something so integral to who I am as a person.
I hope to become one of the first female Eagle Scouts, and when I do, I will join a long line of strong Jewish women who accomplished historic firsts. But my motivation to achieve an Eagle rank isn’t just to be “first,” it’s to learn new skills, to grow as a person, a leader, and a Jew, and, most of all, to internalize these words to live by: “A Scout is trustworthy, loyal, helpful, friendly, courteous, kind, obedient, cheerful, thrifty, brave, clean, and reverent.”
This piece was written as part of JWA’s Rising Voices Fellowship.
How to cite this page
Baran, Nina. "Scout Me In." 3 July 2019. Jewish Women's Archive. (Viewed on October 1, 2022) <https://jwa.org/blog/risingvoices/scout-me>.