Ella, Henny, Sarah, Charlotte, Gertie, and Me

2016-2017 Rising Voices fellow Diana Myers with a copy of the book, "All-of-a Kind Family" by Sydney Taylor.

When I was still pretty small—in first grade, or maybe kindergarten—someone gave me a book for my birthday. This wasn’t an unusual event; I’ve received more books as presents in my seventeen years than I think most people end up owning in their entire lifetime. What was unusual was that this book was by a Jewish woman, and about Jewish girls, like me.

All-of-a Kind Family is the first in a five book series by Sydney Taylor about a large family on the Lower East Side of New York City in the early 20th century. The books are written as a collection of short stories about the daily adventures of five Jewish sisters: they go to the candy store, the library, the market; they have trouble in school; they attend Sukkot and Purim parties; they meet people in the neighborhood and bring them home for Shabbat dinner. The girls’ parents and an assortment of cheerful aunts and uncles round out the picture. The series is mundane in the most comforting of ways, and by the last book every sister was my friend.

I read these books over and over when I was in elementary school, and my copies show it. The cover of All-of-a Kind Family is beginning to fall off, the pages of More All-of-a Kind Family are stuck together by some long ago afternoon snack, and my dog ate most of All-of-a Kind Family Downtown. For reasons I couldn’t explain at the time, I was intensely drawn to Ella, Henny, Sarah, Charlotte and Gertie. They were among the few Jewish female characters I had access to, and I cherished them. Enough of their experiences mirrored my own that I had no problem fitting them into my dress-up and pretend games. Long family dinners on Passover? Been there, suffered through that. Going to school and explaining to goyische (non-Jewish) classmates that I would be out for the next few days because of yet another holiday? That was me, without fail, every fall.

Lately there’s been an increased call for diversity in the media, especially among children’s media, because there’s much evidence that it’s immensely helpful for kids of all backgrounds to understand and appreciate differences. What representation also does is help the “different kids” feel less alone. Having access to stories about Jewish girls was incredibly important to minimizing how weird I sometimes felt at school. My classmates may not have understood the beautiful traditions I was raised with, and too often I felt left out of the hype leading up to Christmas break, but All-of-a Kind Family told me that these relatively minor struggles ultimately didn’t matter because of course my Judaism should be an essential part of my life. Reading stories that assumed that my Jewish heritage informed all the parts of my life increased my pride in who I am.

Taylor never intended for her stories about life on the Lower East Side to be published and bring inspiration to other Jewish girls; she wrote them for her own daughter’s amusement and left them in a drawer for years before her husband found the manuscript and submitted it to a writing contest. Taylor hadn’t realized the book’s potential, but it was a major success and spawned the rest of the series. Soon, All-of-a Kind Family became a staple of the late 20th century American-Jewish girl’s bookshelf. Both of my mothers owned the book as kids, as did their friends.

This was all before media representation was seen as paramount for children’s self esteem. Apparently Taylor’s editor urged her to tone down the Jewish content and have the family assume more American identities. In contrast, Taylor decided to handle assimilation pressure by giving the sisters pride in who they were, while still encouraging their curiosity about the diverse city around them. To me, this shows that Taylor recognized the value of providing Jewish girls with stories about themselves and their heritage.

Sydney Taylor started writing for herself and her family, but her stories have brought joy and pride to many. I still adore the All-of-a Kind Family books even though I’ve long since outgrown them, because they remain among the few books I have that are positive and hopeful and celebratory about Jewish identity. The five sisters inspire me to be curious, and kind, and most of all, proud. They are the characters that first-grade me needed to be proud about my Judaism, and they are the characters that twelfth-grade me wants to see more of. I have wanted to be a writer for just about as long as I’ve identified as a reader, and Taylor’s characters and stories encourage me to unashamedly write about the things that are important to me. Thanks to Taylor’s work, that quietly demonstrated just how necessary positive Jewish stories are for young Jews, I know that when I write my own books, I too can weave in themes and characters that will inspire proud Jewish identity among young readers. Every little bit of representation helps.

This article was also published on Teen Voices at Women's eNews.

This piece was written as part of JWA’s Rising Voices Fellowship.

Topics: Children, Fiction
The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

All-of-a-Kind Family was one of my favorite books when I was little. I read it until it fell apart, then taped it up and read it again. I loved the homey, cozy aspect of it, and, wished that I had a family that close knit.

I am not Jewish, but, I have a great respect for Judaism. I loved learning about the customs and observances through this book. I wanted so much to go to the market with Mama and the girls, and spend my after lunch penny on something delicious and share it with my sisters, then have a beautiful meal together, followed by book time. I wanted to eat hamentaschen on Purim and go visiting family and friends. I wanted to jump into the book and be the sixth sister (maybe Sarah's twin, so we could be the landing in the steps and stairs.)

Thank you for writing this blog and reminding me of how wonderful this book is!

I always loved the five All-of-a-Kind sisters and read the books over and over when I was a girl... and then I read them to each of my seven kids!  Wonderful stuff.  When writing one of my own novels, Bundle of Trouble, for American Girl, about Rebecca growing up in NYC in 1914, I kept picturing Ella, Henny, Sarah, CHarlotte and Gertie's apartment!

Really interesting read about diversity and inclusion in the media for children! Love it!

How to cite this page

Myers, Diana. "Ella, Henny, Sarah, Charlotte, Gertie, and Me." 30 December 2016. Jewish Women's Archive. (Viewed on October 2, 2023) <https://jwa.org/blog/risingvoices/ella-henny-sarah-charlotte-gertie-and-me>.

Read the latest from JWA from your inbox.

sign up now