You are here

Share Share Share Share Share Share Share
Blog:
Jewesses with Attitude

About Circumcision

A proposal to ban circumcision will be on the San Francisco ballot this November.

As a Jewish Mama, my response should fall somewhere along the lines of outrage and a head-tisk.

And as a bleeding heart Mama, my response should be somewhere in the range of agreement and an apology to my son.

I whole-heartedly feel all of these emotions. In other words, I’m conflicted.

I don’t agree with the circumcision ban. But you might be surprised why.

Read more at TCJewfolk >>

Galit Breen is an Israeli freezing her tuchus in Minnesota. She’s a Mama of three currently working on her first book about teaching children spirituality outside of religion. She blogs as the "Minnesota Mamaleh" for TCJewfolk.

2 Comments

Yes I have a son and a grandson, both circumcised. Yes, it probably hurt for a bit--I suppose a pierced ear does too, though I don't know about that. But to ban circumcision (or pierced ears) seems a kind of autocracy that doesn't bode well. Circumcision is not a matter of personal adornment but rather a mark of belonging to an ancient tradition, a tradition (a belief system?) that has been threatened as long as circumcision itself has stood as a mark of belonging. It has been reported that males who have been circumcised seem to have some better chance to avoid sexually transmitted diseases; for some that might be justification enough for allowing the procedure. But the ban smacks of a covert attempt to deny to Muslims and Jews a part of their heritage. I hope Jewish communities in California and elsewhere will vote against the ban....

I had something to say about this issue, and ignited a firestorm of feedback - some of it quite virulent.

http://blogs.forward.com/siste...

Brit Milah
Full image

Brit Milah.

Image by Chesdovi.

How to cite this page

Breen, Galit. "About Circumcision." 17 June 2011. Jewish Women's Archive. (Viewed on February 26, 2017) <https://jwa.org/blog/about-circumcision>.

Donate

Help us elevate the voices of Jewish women.

donate now

Poll

What is the best Jewish feminist tv show currently on tv?

Sign Up for JWA eNews

 

Twitter

1 day
. in the on the Trump administration's habitual refusal to bow to conventions of hypocrisy. https://t.co/jy2EPzjcOV
1 day
Hm, this question can be applied to so many issues. Should people who say heinous things be dismissed or debated? https://t.co/N5sgr26O9A
1 day
RBG tells she'll stay on the Supreme Court as long as she can. Oh, Ruth. We hope that means forever. https://t.co/kGV5yofCda