A Fifth Question for Passover

The Passover Seder offers an opportunity to remember more than just the exodus from Egypt and our desert wanderings. Adding an orange or Miriam’s Cup to the Seder plate or a special reading to the ritual emphasizes our concern for contemporary social justice ills, even as we recite again our historic persecutions and plagues.

This year I propose bringing a Fifth Question to the table: Why should access to reproductive health care be preserved? The proverbial Four Children posing the traditional Four Questions could ask the Fifth according to the distinctive manner of each.

  • The Wise Child: What makes this a Jewish issue, and how do our texts and traditions address it?
  • The Simple Child: Why wasn’t I aborted?
  • The Child Unable To Inquire: Why is this issue important right now?
  • The Mocking Child: Why should I care, if it doesn’t affect me?

Rabbis Raymond Zwerin and Richard Shapiro, in an article written for the Religious Coalition for Reproductive Choice, address four aspects of reproductive medicine dealt with in Jewish writings: the legal status of the embryo and fetus, the emergence of the soul, conditions permitting therapeutic abortion and those regarding non-therapeutic procedures.

What could be called therapeutic abortion first surfaces in a second century text quoted in the Mishnah. But the Torah offers evidence from Genesis 21:22 that the unborn child is not a legal person by positing that the perpetrator of a miscarriage could be fined but not punished as severely as the murderer of a living person. The Talmud treats the fetus as the “thigh of its mother,” simply a part of the pregnant woman’s body with the potential to become a human being. However, realization of that potential comes with emergence from the birth canal. Judaism’s value for life extends to self-defense. Therefore, pregnancy or labor threatening the mother’s life makes therapeutic abortion permissible.

The genesis of the soul is esoteric and controversial. (How Jewish is that?) Arguments range from the moment of intercourse to when a child begins to speak. Some rabbis safely lump this into “secrets of God” that will only be answered when the Messiah comes. A non-issue regarding abortion decisions among Jews.

Sanction for non-therapeutic abortion is not clear-cut. The pain of the mother offers guidelines here. This standard applies for rape, incest and mental health considerations including potentially suicidal anguish.

However, modern medical technology that affords a preview of fetal illness (including genetic ones, such as Tay-Sachs), HIV-infection, Down’s Syndrome and drug addiction does not provide a license for abortion. Preserving life, like that of the “Simple Child,” doesn’t only apply to the mother, even if the new life will be predictably imperfect.

With the Wise and Simple sufficiently answered, it’s time to reply to the implicit question of the Child Unable to Inquire. Why speak out now, 38 years after Roe v.Wade made abortion safe and legal?

Can the recent budget battle and bills already passed in the House of Representatives leave anyone in doubt about timeliness? The bills gut reproductive choice by aiming to restrict abortion after rape that’s not “forcible,” incest when the female is over a certain age (16 or 18) and even when saving the life of the mother offends the consciences of attending medical professionals. New laws in several states target women’s rights in unique but similarly draconian ways. There’s no enormous constitutional threat to Roe v. Wade coming to the Supreme Court yet, but the prevailing winds are not blowing in the right direction.

Finally, to the Mocking Child and, frankly, to anyone not directly affected and thereby self-excluded from “household of Israel” and the need to care. You may be old enough to remember the back alley or young enough to take the freedoms accessible since 1973 for granted. Either way, is a country that turns the clock back to that time what you want for yourself, for your children or grandchildren—for “the strangers among us”? It’s not just about abortion. It’s about access to family planning, mammograms and other preventive medical best practices. It’s about keeping providers such as Planned Parenthood open. And it’s also about restrictions on private health insurance, including employer-sponsored plans, constraining even the most deluxe coverage.

The Haggadah has taught us to remember and to educate about the importance of life and Jewish tradition in the face of outside threats. No matter what form those threats take.

Linda Frank, San Francisco, is the author of the (Passover-related) novel, After the Auction.

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

I realize that I am a little late to this party, but just wanted to suggest a verse to think about. Psalms 139:13-14
I was a special education teacher. I saw lots of kids with all sorts of disabilities. Some of them may have been better off if they had not survived, while others (who doctors thought would be nothing but a burden to their families) have grown up and had good lives. So, who should make the decisions about these kids? Tay-Sachs, there is no up side to a child who will suffer and die. But kids wih Down syndrome, who are HIV positive, who have cerebral palsy, who is to choose "who shall live and who shall die?"

I think "simple" is a pretty insulting word for somebody with mental disabilities these days. And it's pretty insulting to have the "simple child" ask "Why wasn't I aborted?" as though parents of children with mental disabilites all do or should consider abortion. I mean, how would you feel about a haggadah with three sons asking the three other questions, and then the daughter asks "Why wasn't I aborted?" Female lives aren't worth less, and neither are the lives of people with disabilities.

 I know this haggadah wasn't meant to be insulting to people with disabilities. But it certainly comes across that way, so I hope you will consider a rewrite of that part.

Just to clarify, this blog post is NOT an excerpt from the JWA Haggadah or related to the Haggadah in any way.

In this blog post, the author uses the "Four Children" from the seder as a vehicle to discuss why reproductive rights are so important.

Sorry if this was unclear!

Read the latest from JWA from your inbox.

sign up now


Help us elevate the voices of Jewish women.

donate now

Get JWA in your inbox

Read the latest from JWA from your inbox.

sign up now

How to cite this page

Frank, Linda. "A Fifth Question for Passover." 14 April 2011. Jewish Women's Archive. (Viewed on April 16, 2024) <http://jwa.org/blog/a-fifth-question-for-passover>.