You are here

Share Share Share Share Share Share Share

Too Much Christmas?

by KG

Rather than stay fixated on last year’s “war against Christmas,” dust-up, the New York Times this holiday season has been running a veritable flood of articles suggesting that, when it comes to Christmas: if you can’t beat ‘em, join ‘em. No less than seven articles have put forward the argument that even those who might have good reason to distance themselves from Christmas tend to be happier (and less curmudgeonly) when they simply embrace the holiday that everyone loves.

The first article that I noticed in this unintended series was a December 17 news article focusing on a number of prominent athiests who suggest that Christmas has become so “divorced” from religion that they feel little conflict over indulging in its celebration. The majority of the articles on this topic, however, have focused upon Jews (a number of the atheists are also identified as being of Jewish background). A December 20 article entitled ”Los Angeles Journal” for instance, described a Christmas display that was wreaking havoc not only because it was illuminating a predominantly Jewish (and orthodox) neighborhood, but because the woman behind all the lights and huge blow-up Christmas characters was herself Jewish. The article reports on complaints from some of the neighbors and the display owner’s response that “I don’t think candy canes have anything to do with religion.” It concludes with the question posed by one neighbor (“a British Jew”): “why don’t Jewish people decorate more?”

Three articles, which all ran on Christmas eve, offer slightly embarrassed admissions by Jewish authors of the powerful role that Christmas has played in either their youthful or adult lives. Finally, a piece by guest op-ed columnist Orlando Patterson on December 23 offered a useful frame on all the articles, arguing that American Christmases are such a pastiche of contributions from America’s different ethnic groups, that no one should object to it as anything other than a quintessentially American holiday. Patterson suggests that the “muted Christian element” of an American Christmas should be no less alienating to non-Christians than the Christian-inflected art of Botticelli or Fra Angelico. In his view, we should be able to celebrate Christmas without buying into Christianity, just as we might be able to enjoy jazz “without much caring for black culture.”

These articles suggest that Christmas is so fun and good and so – thanks to the openness of American society -- available to all, that there is little reason not to participate. As many note, much of its celebration grows out of pagan customs anyway, and as one letter to the editor from an agreeable atheist inveighed: why not “celebrate what we have in common rather than sitting out the season because of what we disagree on.”

But I find other, more sobering, messages in this “let’s all celebrate” journalism.

For one thing, these articles powerfully reflect what we all know: the pervasiveness and total penetration of Christmas culture in American lives. Their testimony to the irresistibility of Christmas also illuminates just how hard it is to maintain distinctive identities that push against mainstream American patterns.

Another message conveyed in these articles is that religious traditions are interchangeable. Orlando Patterson rhapsodizes about how soothing and glorious a public Christmas tree decorated with menorahs would be. Cindy Chupack suggests that, although she is currently luxuriating in Christmas pleasures that she was denied as a Jewish girl, when it comes to having kids, she and her husband will probably go back to the “eight days is better than one” philosophy. But she ends by suggesting that it might be “nice to teach children that holidays can be done a la carte,” teaching tolerance by drawing upon the beautiful traditions of many cultures.

It’s safe to assume that most American children from all backgrounds will grow up, like I did, fluent in Christmas – able to sing dozens of Christmas carols and well versed in Christmas narratives ranging from the manger, to the North Pole to 34th Street. But if Jewish parents at Christmas time cannot let their children know that these festivities, these lights, these carols, these stories, this birthday, are not theirs – then how will they ever be able to convey any sense of distinctive identity in a culture so intent on stamping us all the same?

Perhaps it would be more Christmas-like to suggest that the world would be better off if we could just unite around peace on earth and goodwill toward men. But to give these familiar phrases meaning – to raise them above the season’s commercial blare -- Christmas needs to be more than a bland concoction of holiday cheer and eggnog easily adapted by pagans, atheists, Jews and Muslims alike. Those who celebrate it should stop pretending that it’s not named after Christ. It may be unsettling to acknowledge just how much a Christian celebration structures so much of American life -- our economy, our calendar (as relates to school, work, leisure, and family), and so much of our cultural vocabulary. It might, however, clarify the need that some of us have to maintain what distance we can from its omnipresent celebration.

Christmas is very much with all of us. I’m quite content to walk down my street and enjoy the trees in other people’s windows – but I do not need one in my own. I don’t think this makes me a bad American – I ‘d rather believe that a society that is able to make room for even this small measure of difference is one that might find a way to offer true respect and inclusion for all its members.

Share Share Share Share Share Share Share

I loved the line, "Those who celebrate [Christmas] should stop pretending that it's not named after Christ". I wanna make a t-shirt! It expresses what I've felt for years whenever I hear Jews go out of their way to say how they miss Christmas.

I'm not ashamed to admit that I revel in December 25th and January 1st being just another day. While Christmas and New Years have followed me here (to Israel), they have about as much influence as Chanuka in Kansas City.

It's high time we admitted that knowing all the words to "Silent Night" is not cute, it's a shame.

First of all, I loved your statement, "Those who celebrate Christmas should stop pretending that it's not named after Christ." Right on. I'm quite uncomfortable with Jews who wax nostalgic about their tolerant, Christmas-invaded childhoods. As my neighbor likes to say, "Let's not be so open-minded that our brains fall out."

One thing I like about living in Israel is that December 25th is just that, and so is January 1st (OK, Christmas and New Year's Eve have followed me here, but their effect is about as strong as that of Chanuka in Kansas City). Anyway, you might be interested in what I wrote on the subject in my blog, which combines Christmas and the Gilmore Girls! PS I like how easy it is to comment on your blog.

I was taken with the following conclusion in the original blogger's piece: "a society that is able to make room for even this small measure of difference is one that might find a way to offer true respect and inclusion for all its members." In our oh-so-assimilated culture we are so afraid to be branded as "other." Some of us grew up as little Jewish girls in largely Catholic communities, others grew up as rather non-religious Jews in cities and towns where most of our friends went to one church or another. The world will always identify us as Jews -- different, other, perhaps even strange, but I want to live in a society where I am free to celebrate what is unique to Judaism, if I like, without having to explain myself. I want to be allowed the freedom to self-identify as someone who does not celebrate Christmas. I am tired of trying to explain to friends that Santa Claus has, indeed, come to be seen as a "Christian" figure (even if we draw his origins back to more pagan ceremony). I want to light and display my lit menorah if I choose--without feeling I must compete with the colored lights elsewhere in my neighborhood. And wouldn't it be refreshing if a neighbor asked, "So...tell me about this holiday you are celebrating with your candles?" And no, it is not the "Jewish Christmas." Room for inclusion is what I seek. Our society needs to find room for inclusion in so very many ways. This is but one small piece where change would be welcome.

Interestingly, I found this Ì¢‰âÒflood of articlesÌ¢‰âÂå demonstrating the ease with which many are able to celebrate Christmas with little or no regard for the religious underpinnings very reassuring. I am an atheist who was raised by a Jewish father and a Lutheran mother. I celebrate Christmas and pretend it has nothing to do with religion and I donÌ¢‰â‰ã¢t feel guilty about taking that stance. However, the piece Ì¢‰âÒToo Much ChristmasÌ¢‰âÂå caused me to reconsider. In many ways it illuminated how difficult it is for those who choose not to celebrate Christmas, how it overpowers our culture and society, how important it is to maintain Ì¢‰âÒdistinctive identitiesÌ¢‰âÂå within the broader culture. But what is missing in this piece is the complication of interfaith marriages and the challenge of negotiating the holiday season in mixed-faith families. Over one-third of American Jews are married to Christians. I believe that these families probably struggle quite a bit to create meaningful holiday experiences that respect and support each partnerÌ¢‰â‰ã¢s unique religious background.

Subscribe to Jewish Women, Amplified and get notifications sent to your email.

How to cite this page

KG. "Too Much Christmas?." 27 December 2006. Jewish Women's Archive. (Viewed on January 24, 2018) <>.


Help us elevate the voices of Jewish women.

donate now

The JWA Podcast

listen now


Who is your favorite historical Jewish feminist named Emma?

Sign Up for JWA eNews



8 hr
So wonderful to read the long-lost story of this icon.
8 hr it just us, or is there something missing from this list of Jewish Oscar nominees?